Protest arrest & answers to common town questions

This is the third in a series of four posts on related subjects. Yes I’m a selectboard member; no I’m not speaking for the board or the town. (As if I could!)

This will be the first time I have publicly discussed this, because I prefer focus not be on myself when hundreds of children and workers in scrubs are found in mass graves on hospital grounds with their hands zip-tied behind their backs. But since it’s been mentioned around town: I was among the 90 arrested at the protest at Dartmouth on May 1. It was a principled stand in the tradition of a dozen mass student-led movements spanning American history, which created changes we all consider good. These changes simply didn’t happen until thousands (or tens of thousands) were arrested at hundreds of protests.

People in power seem to only like protest action that exists politely in the periphery. Perhaps so they can ignore it. If you think protests need to be polite, to be officially permitted—such that they can be ignored—then it’s possible you don’t fully grasp what protest is for.

The arrested Dartmouth protesters, 73 of whom are students and faculty including former Jewish Studies Chair Annelise Orleck, will have our day in court, assisted in defense by the NH ACLU. We will use the court to speak. Again, that’s largely what Hartford residents pay me $100 every two weeks to do: to speak on behalf of what I’m hearing. What I did getting arrested isn’t much, but it added to the numbers, in solidarity. If we all do a little, if we all speak and demand and do a little, maybe things will budge.

Fighting for justice “over there” *IS* fighting for justice here. It sets the standard that no one can be starved or blown to bits in the name of capital, hegemony, or anything else. All have dignity. Including us. Gazans would do the same for us; indeed they literally have. They’ve stood up in protest of all kinds of things: lack of U.S. civil rights, apartheid in South Africa, income inequality when our banners decryed the chokehold of “the 1%.” Crucially, however, we and Gazans stand for one another not out of reciprocity, but because it’s right.

To the idea that I’m an “individual member pushing my agenda,” that’s only true in small part. Sure, I’m acting on what I believe, but this is no different than how other board members act, in that I’m also supporting hundreds of folks in town who happen to share these beliefs. We shouldn’t let anyone silence the beliefs of a group of citizens by trying to ascribe those beliefs to a single representative alone.

I’m also here supporting the hundreds of students and community members who came out to protest May 1, and the hundreds who support sending a message to our national representatives via a ceasefire resolution. One gentleman cited a chapter of Vermont law that outlines the limited powers selectboard members have. That’s why the worth of a resolution—which the state grants us the power to make—is merely in its ability to send a message. We’ll soon decide whether this message is worthwhile.

Judging by how often it comes up, folks seem to want to assume the board neglects “the business of the town.” Especially if it’s made known that in our free time, we think about non-town things. (Or in this case, how non-town things affect our town.) Anyway, below is a response to questions posted here yesterday, sent by the town manager after I passed around an early draft of a response. I’m spreading the response because others may wish for updates on the same subjects.

Fairview Terrace retaining wall: “The Selectboard has heard from design engineers who have opined on project costs and the Selectboard has approved of a plan to propose a $4,100,000.00 bond to the voters in November to support construction to allow the road to be reopened to one-way traffic.”

Former Hartford Diner site: “As Brandon has stated, there is pending litigation. However, I share your concerns over this eyesore and hope to find the best way to clean up the site, without running afoul of the property rights of others. This may require the Town to take title to the parcel, at least long enough to perform the needed cleanup work.”

Status of replacing aging/failing water lines in Wilder: “We have engineers working on design and we expect work to begin this year.”

Accessible doors to the Bugbee Senior Center: “The Town has architects designing needed improvements to the facility, including ADA access.”

The listserv has its limitations, so if you’d like to hear what I have to say without this filter, email hey@brandonsmith.com to be included in future mailings.

Divesting our livelihoods from mass suffering

This is the second in a series of four posts on related subjects. Yes I’m a selectboard member; no I’m not speaking for the board or the town. (As if I could!)

Did you know that almost four months ago, the death toll in Gaza largely stopped being counted because most of the people who did the counting—medical and public health professionals—had been killed by American-made bombs? We hear that 40,000 people have died, but we no longer really know. Chances are it’s much higher. Israel just bombed 1.5 million people living in a massive tent city, forcing them to evacuate yet again.

Does it sound remotely like a proportional response to you—proportional response is technically international law—to destroy the homes and civic infrastructure of 1.7 million of Gaza’s 2 million people, kill many tens of thousands, and starve hundreds of thousands, after an attack that killed 1,200? (Especially given that Israel refuses to investigate how many of those deaths were from Israeli “friendly” fire.) The U.N. hasn’t thought it proportionate. As of two weeks ago, Israel had violated 62 U.N. resolutions and counting. When Iraq violated two, we launched a ground invasion of their country.

To all who think this irrelevant to Hartford, ask yourself how much of our economy comes from Dartmouth and Dartmouth hospital. (If we’re honest, it’s a huge percentage.) Dartmouth has six billion dollars in accounts which are, as we speak, political tools to prop up the business concerns these assets are invested in—including weapons manufacturers and countless others profiting from Gaza’s immolation. If you live off the local economy, like I do, then you live off the returns of these investments. That’s how directly we benefit from the murder of Palestinians.

I’ve mentioned that Hartford residents alone have sent $2.8 million in weapons to Israel since October. And yet, the value generated by Dartmouth’s investments is far greater than our direct contribution. That’s why protest is necessary: our livelihoods shouldn’t be derived from how profitable it is to starve brown people or slaughter doctors and journalists. The professors were right Monday evening when they voted, for the first time in the college’s history, to censure their president for her role in the arrest of ~75 students protesting for their institution’s divestment.

The listserv has its limitations, so if you’d like to hear what I have to say without this filter, email hey@brandonsmith.com to be included in future mailings.